Potbelly is the warm-toasted-sandwich specialist a lot of offices reach for when lunch calls for subs: every sandwich runs through the brand’s signature oven, including the ones inside the Boxed Lunches and the Box O’ Sandwiches tray, while peer national sandwich chains ship cold for catering. But offices that try to make Potbelly a regular catering choice keep running into the same walls. The menu is toasted subs, salads, mac and soup, and cookies and shakes, which is bread-forward and gets repetitive on a weekly rotation, with no hot entrees or global variety. Catering is built on pre-composed Boxed Lunches and trays, with no shared build-your-own bar and no on-site staffing. Its footprint is roughly 471 shops concentrated in the Midwest, about a quarter of them in Illinois, so plenty of offices are out of range. And while gluten-free bread is available for about a dollar more, it is made in a shared kitchen and the menu runs thin on vegan depth. Below are 8 Potbelly catering alternatives that each solve at least one of those problems, ordered from the closest sub-shop swaps to the broader, more flexible upgrades. For everything Potbelly does offer, see our Potbelly Catering Guide.
In This Guide
Why Look Beyond Potbelly Catering?
Potbelly earns its spot: the toasted sandwich is genuinely distinctive, the Boxed Lunches drop neatly onto a conference-room table, and a quick sub lunch is an easy crowd-pleaser. But five issues come up again and again when offices try to make it a regular catering choice.
- Toasted sandwiches only, and bread-forward. The catering menu is subs, salads, mac and soup, and cookies and shakes. There are no hot entrees and no global variety, so it leans carb-heavy and gets repetitive on a weekly rotation.
- Pre-boxed format, not a build-your-own bar. Catering arrives as pre-composed Boxed Lunches and the Box O’ Sandwiches tray. There is no shared build-your-own sandwich or deli bar where the team self-portions and customizes, and no on-site staffing or setup included.
- A concentrated footprint. With roughly 471 shops clustered in the Midwest, about 24% of them in Illinois, Potbelly simply is not an option for many offices. If there is no shop nearby, catering is off the table.
- Thin dietary depth. Gluten-free bread is available for about a dollar more, but it is prepared in a shared kitchen with cross-contamination risk, and the menu runs light on vegan and protein-forward options for a mixed team.
- A $50 catering minimum. Smaller team lunches can bump into the order minimum, which makes Potbelly less flexible for a quick spread for a handful of people.
If any of those sound familiar, here are 8 alternatives worth trying. Potbelly is strong on the toasted-sub experience, so the bar for a swap is keeping that easy, crowd-pleasing lunch quality while fixing menu range, format, reach, or dietary coverage.
8 Potbelly Catering Alternatives for Your Office
1. Jersey Mike’s: The Closest National Swap, Fresh-Sliced and Far-Reaching
Jersey Mike’s is the closest national swap when you want a sub-shop lunch but fresher and with broader reach. Meats and cheeses are sliced to order, the Mike’s Way build adds onions, lettuce, tomatoes, oil, vinegar, and spices, and the footprint reaches far more offices than Potbelly.
Quick stats: $11 to $15 per person | Cold subs sliced to order + box lunches + sub trays | 24 hours lead time | Roughly 3,000 US locations, open 7 days
Jersey Mike’s trades Potbelly’s toasting for fresh-sliced meats and a customizable Mike’s Way build, and with roughly 3,000 locations it reaches offices Potbelly’s Midwest-heavy footprint cannot. The box lunches scale cleanly for hybrid and distributed teams, and the made-to-order slicing keeps quality high. See our Jersey Mike’s Catering Guide for the full breakdown.
2. Jimmy John’s: Fast Delivery and Budget-Friendly Box Lunches
Jimmy John’s is the move when speed and price matter most. Its Freaky Fast delivery, simple box lunches, and party platters make it one of the easiest, lowest-sticker-price sub options for a same-day office lunch.
Quick stats: $9 to $13 per person | Cold subs + box lunches + party platters | Same-day delivery in many markets | Thousands of US locations, open 7 days
If a last-minute lunch and a tight budget are the priority, Jimmy John’s is hard to beat: it is built around fast delivery, the box lunches are among the cheapest of the national chains, and its footprint is broad. Like Potbelly, the menu is sandwich-centric, so it is a swap for reach and speed rather than variety. See our Jimmy John’s Catering Guide, or order at jimmyjohns.com/catering.
3. Local Delis & Sandwich Shops via Zerocater: Authentic, Often Fresher and Cheaper
A local deli or sandwich shop is the most direct peer to Potbelly: the same sandwich-and-sides spread, frequently made that morning, often at a lower per-head price, and far more flexible on bread, fillings, and dietary swaps than a fixed chain menu.
Quick stats: $10 to $15 per person | Fresh sandwiches + sides + salads, platters or boxed | 24 to 48 hours lead time | Local in most metros, available 7 days
If the team specifically wants sandwiches but Potbelly’s pricing, repetition, or reach is the sticking point, an independent deli hits the same note, usually better. Sandwiches are made locally, the menu flexes to your budget and dietary needs, and ordering through Zerocater means a managed delivery instead of a shop-by-shop order. Browse deli and sandwich caterers on Zerocater: TOGO’S and Erik’s DeliCafe in the Bay Area, Arturo’s Deli and Bon Bon Sandwiches in Chicago, New York Deli News in Denver, Tivoli Sandwiches in Boston, and Al’s Delicatessen in New York.
4. Jason’s Deli: A Broader Deli With a Salad Bar and Hot Options
Jason’s Deli is the swap when toasted subs feel too narrow. Beyond sandwiches and wraps, it brings a salad bar, soups, hot box lunches, and free soft-serve, with a nationwide footprint and a reputation for clean, preservative-free ingredients.
Quick stats: $11 to $16 per person | Sandwiches + salad bar + soups + hot box lunches | 24 hours lead time | Locations across major US markets, open 7 days
Jason’s Deli covers the same approachable lane as Potbelly but with far more range: a salad bar and soups round out the sandwiches, the box lunches travel well, and the menu is easier to point dietary-restricted guests toward. It is a strong pick when one caterer needs to please a sandwich crowd and a salad crowd at once. See our Jason’s Deli Catering Alternatives for where it fits and where a local caterer does better.
5. McAlister’s Deli: Hot Sandwiches, Spuds, and Famous Sweet Tea
McAlister’s Deli is the move when you want a deli with hot options Potbelly does not carry. Toasted and grilled sandwiches, giant baked spuds, soups, salads, and its signature sweet tea make for a more substantial, Southern-leaning spread.
Quick stats: $11 to $16 per person | Hot and cold sandwiches + baked spuds + soups and salads | 24 hours lead time | Locations across the South and Midwest, open 7 days
McAlister’s brings warm, filling options that a toasted-sub menu lacks, especially the loaded baked spuds, and the soups and salads add variety for a mixed team. It is a good fit for an office that wants something heartier than a cold sandwich box without leaving the deli lane entirely. See our McAlister’s Deli Catering Alternatives for the full comparison.
6. Build-Your-Own Sandwich & Deli Bar: The Communal Format Potbelly Lacks
A build-your-own sandwich or deli bar from a local caterer is the most direct fix for Potbelly’s pre-boxed format. One generous, self-serve station of breads, sliced meats and cheeses, spreads, and toppings that the whole team builds from, often staffed.
Quick stats: $12 to $18 per person | Self-serve sandwich or deli bar, often staffed | 24 to 48 hours lead time | Local in most metros, available 7 days
Instead of a stack of identical pre-composed Boxed Lunches, a deli bar lets everyone build and customize their own sandwich, which feels more abundant and covers a mixed-diet team from one layout. It is the communal, flexible format Potbelly catering does not offer, and a local caterer can staff the station for a client-facing lunch or an all-hands. For the full playbook, see our Build Your Own Sandwich Bar guide. Browse local delis on Zerocater, including Deli Market Co in New York and Erik’s DeliCafe in the Bay Area.
7. Mediterranean & Bowl Caterers: Protein-Forward and Beyond Sandwiches
Mediterranean and bowl caterers are the upgrade when you want to leave sandwiches behind entirely. Shawarma and grilled chicken, falafel, grain bowls, rice, salads, hummus, and mezze that are protein-forward, fresh, and naturally cover more diets.
Quick stats: $12 to $20 per person | Bowls and platters + mezze, buffet or family-style | 24 to 48 hours lead time | Local in most metros, available 7 days
This is the swap for teams tired of bread-forward lunches: a Mediterranean or bowl spread is hot, fresh, and built around lean proteins and vegetables, and it covers gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan eaters far more naturally than a toasted-sub box. For more ideas, see our Healthy Office Catering guide. Browse Mediterranean catering and Greek catering on Zerocater, including SAJJ Mediterranean and Kali Greek Kitchen in the Bay Area, Zaatar Mediterranean in San Francisco, Baal Cafe and Falafel and Zazu Mediterranean in New York, and Boston Shawarma in Boston.
8. Local Caterers via Zerocater: The Full Upgrade
The biggest limitation of every chain on this list is that you are still ordering from a single restaurant with a fixed menu, fixed format, and whatever price and reach it sets. When you order through Zerocater, you get access to 1,000-plus vetted caterers across every style, including delis and sandwich shops, build-your-own bars, Mediterranean and bowl kitchens, and full hot-entree spreads, all available seven days a week with managed delivery and setup, in metros where Potbelly has no shop at all.
Quick stats: Varies by caterer | Same-day ordering available | Setup, serving staff, and cleanup options | Available in major metro areas, 7 days
What sets local caterers apart from a chain: pricing that flexes to your budget rather than a fixed franchise menu, a shared build-your-own sandwich or deli bar when you want one, hot and global options alongside the sandwiches, dietary needs (including gluten-free) scoped per order, staffed setup for client-facing lunches, and coverage anywhere Zerocater operates. For a lunch program that stays interesting week to week, see our Office Manager’s Guide to Ordering Catering and our guide to the best boxed lunch catering companies.
With CaterAi, you describe your event (headcount, budget, dietary needs) and get custom menu suggestions from multiple restaurants in minutes. Try CaterAi now.
Potbelly Alternatives at a Glance
| Alternative | Style | Price/Person | Beyond Toasted Subs? | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jersey Mike’s | Fresh-sliced cold subs + trays | $11–$15 | Still subs, fresher + Mike’s Way | Closest swap, broader reach |
| Jimmy John’s | Cold subs + box lunches | $9–$13 | Still subs, fast + cheap | Same-day, budget lunches |
| Local Delis | Fresh sandwiches + sides | $10–$15 | Flexible menu and swaps | Authentic peer, fresher and cheaper |
| Jason’s Deli | Sandwiches + salad bar + soups | $11–$16 | Yes (salad bar + hot box lunches) | Pleasing a mixed team |
| McAlister’s Deli | Hot sandwiches + spuds + soups | $11–$16 | Yes (hot options + baked spuds) | Heartier, warm deli spread |
| Build-Your-Own Deli Bar | Self-serve sandwich station | $12–$18 | Customizable per guest | Communal, staffed, mixed-diet teams |
| Mediterranean & Bowls | Shawarma, falafel, grain bowls, mezze | $12–$20 | Yes (no sandwiches, strong GF/veg) | Protein-forward, fresh, healthy |
| Local via Zerocater | Any style, managed | Varies | Yes, scoped per order | The full upgrade, anywhere |
Skip the Chain: Order Local Through CaterAi
Every chain on this list solves one or two of Potbelly’s gaps, but none solves all of them, and you are still locked into a single restaurant’s menu, format, and footprint. The real upgrade is to stop thinking chain-first. Potbelly is a fine toasted-sub lunch, but a fresh local deli is usually better and cheaper, a broader deli or Mediterranean spread fixes the variety, a build-your-own bar fixes the format, and a local caterer reaches offices the chain cannot. CaterAi lets you get all of those in one place.
Tell CaterAi your headcount, budget, and dietary needs, and it builds custom lunch menus from 1,000-plus local caterers in minutes, then lets you chat to swap items, add staffing or setup, and check out. For ongoing lunch programs, see corporate catering; for a one-off client lunch or all-hands, see corporate event catering; and for the full picture, see how Zerocater works.
Plan Your Office Lunch with CaterAi
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best alternative to Potbelly for office catering?
It depends on what is pushing you off Potbelly. If you want the same easy sub-shop lunch but fresher and with broader reach, Jersey Mike’s is the closest national swap, slicing meats and cheeses to order across roughly 3,000 locations. Jimmy John’s is the fast-delivery pick for box lunches. If toasted sandwiches simply get repetitive, a broader deli like Jason’s Deli or McAlister’s adds soups, salad bars, hot options, and baked spuds. The biggest upgrade is ordering through Zerocater, which connects you with 1,000-plus local delis, build-your-own bars, and Mediterranean and bowl caterers with staffed setup, in metros where Potbelly has no shop.
What is a cheaper alternative to Potbelly catering?
Jimmy John’s box lunches are usually the lowest sticker price among the national sub chains, and a local deli booked through Zerocater frequently beats Potbelly per head for the same sandwich-and-sides spread while delivering fresher, made-that-morning food. The biggest savings come from a build-your-own sandwich or deli bar: one shared setup self-portions across the whole team, which usually costs less per head than stacks of pre-composed Boxed Lunches. Always compare all-in pricing including the delivery fee, and watch Potbelly’s $50 catering minimum on smaller orders.
What is a Potbelly alternative with more than sandwiches?
Potbelly catering is toasted subs, salads, mac and shake, plus soup, with no hot entrees or global variety. For a broader spread, Jason’s Deli adds a salad bar, soups, and hot options, and McAlister’s Deli brings baked spuds and hot sandwiches. To leave sandwiches behind entirely, a Mediterranean or bowl caterer serves shawarma, falafel, grain bowls, and mezze that are protein-forward and naturally cover more diets. Ordering through Zerocater lets you pull from 1,000-plus local caterers across every cuisine.
Is Jersey Mike’s or Potbelly better for office catering?
It comes down to hot versus fresh-sliced. Potbelly toasts every sandwich, which is its signature, but its footprint is roughly 471 shops concentrated in the Midwest. Jersey Mike’s slices meats and cheeses fresh to order, offers its Mike’s Way build, and reaches far more offices with roughly 3,000 locations, though most of its catering ships cold. If toasted bread is the whole point, Potbelly wins; if freshness, reach, and a customizable build matter more, Jersey Mike’s is the stronger swap. For the freshest, most flexible option, book a local deli through Zerocater.
What is a good gluten-free or dietary alternative to Potbelly catering?
Potbelly offers gluten-free bread for about a dollar more, but it is prepared in a shared kitchen with cross-contamination risk, and the catering menu is bread-forward with thin vegan depth. For cleaner dietary coverage, a Mediterranean or bowl caterer builds plates around naturally gluten-free and plant-based items; a salad-bar deli like Jason’s Deli lets each guest build to their needs; and a local caterer through Zerocater can be scoped so gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian guests are all covered. See our guides to gluten-free office catering and vegan office catering.
What is a Potbelly alternative with a build-your-own bar?
Potbelly catering is built on pre-composed Boxed Lunches and the Box O’ Sandwiches tray, so it does not offer a true shared, build-your-own setup. The fix is a build-your-own sandwich or deli bar from a local caterer through Zerocater: one station of breads, sliced meats and cheeses, spreads, and toppings that the whole team builds from, often with staffed setup. It gives you the communal, customizable format a stack of boxes cannot, covers mixed diets from one layout, and tends to cost less per head at scale. See our Build Your Own Sandwich Bar guide.
What can I order instead of Potbelly if there is no shop near my office?
Potbelly runs roughly 471 shops concentrated in the Midwest, with about a quarter of them in Illinois, so plenty of offices are out of delivery range. Jersey Mike’s (roughly 3,000 locations) and Jimmy John’s cover far more of the country with sub catering. The most reliable fix is ordering through Zerocater, which connects you with 1,000-plus local delis, sandwich shops, and full-service caterers across every metro, including cities where Potbelly has no presence at all.
How do I cater a healthy office lunch without Potbelly?
A toasted-sub spread is bread-forward and carb-heavy, so the healthiest swaps add lean protein and fresh vegetables. A Mediterranean or bowl caterer brings grilled chicken and falafel, grain bowls, salads, and mezze; a salad-bar deli like Jason’s Deli lets the team build lighter plates; and a build-your-own bar can be scoped around proteins and produce rather than bread. Ordering through Zerocater lets you filter for healthy, vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free coverage. See our guides on healthy office catering and vegetarian office catering.
Related guides: Potbelly Catering Guide | Jersey Mike’s Catering Guide | Jimmy John’s Catering Guide | Jason’s Deli Catering Alternatives | McAlister’s Deli Catering Alternatives | Firehouse Subs Catering Alternatives | Build Your Own Sandwich Bar | Best Boxed Lunch Catering Companies | Healthy Office Catering | Gluten-Free Office Catering | Vegetarian Office Catering | Vegan Office Catering | Mixed Dietary Needs | Office Manager’s Guide | Board Meeting Catering | Corporate Event Catering Checklist
to plan your catering
